Best-Selling Author Marlow Kelly
  • Marlow's Books
  • Contact Me
  • About Marlow

Three Reasons Why You Shouldn't Travel Back in Time

11/2/2013

 
It seems to me that when the medieval period is portrayed
both on screen and in literature we hardly ever see a complete picture of what life was really like. I think this is partly due to storytelling taking precedence over reality; and in part due to the fact that it is almost impossible to recreate history. And do we really want our favorite stories marred with the unhygienic realities of life in the middle ages? I have to admit that I am guilty of this. When I write I concentrate on my characters and setting, and omit the unsavory truths. 
With this in mind, I’m surprised that there is so much fiction involving
time travel. I for one would hate to travel back in time, and here are three
reasons why:- 

Knights and Lords Were Little More Than Murderous Thugs.

The feudal system was such that it rewarded the cruel and punished
the just. So if the king asked you to murder you neighbour, who also happened to be your brother-in-law, you had better be prepared to do it. Or he could accuse you of treason and have you killed instead. Yes, most successful kings were murderous thugs too.

For example; in 1377, in the town of Cesena, Italy, John
Hawkwood, an English knight, and his company of mercenaries massacred between 2500 and 8000 men, women, and children.
He was under orders from Cardinal Robert of Geneva, who in turn was acting in the name of Pope Gregory XI. After a lifetime of murdering and pillaging for money, Hawkwood is said to have retired to England as a country gentlemen.
It hardly seems fair does it?

No Tea or Coffee. Both tea and coffee were unknown
in the middle ages. With tea originating in China and coffee in Ethiopia both drinks made their way to Europe at the beginning of the seventeenth century. 
So, as a peasant, (and yes, most of us would have been peasants) you would wake up in the morning, if you were lucky you owned a bed and a blanket. Your feet would hit the frozen dirt floor of your stone hut and your breakfast would consist of last night’s leftovers. Leaving you to face the stark reality of a cold, damp morning without a single drop of caffeine. I don’t know how mankind survived 

And lastly and most importantly

No Indoor plumbing. Not only was there no plumbing there was no clean drinking water. Everyone, including the children, drank a
weak fermented liquid called small beer. So by the end of the day you might be pretty sloshed. And just imagine that after facing your morning without a daily cup of Joe you would also have to deal with the fact that your bathroom was a hole in the ground? or if you lived in the country, a bush?
Can you imagine the smell from the open sewers? Let alone the diseases this lack of sanitation would create.
Some of you might rough it when go on holiday and call it
camping and you might even enjoy it. Personally, I don’t call it camping I call it cruel and unusual punishment, and it’s my number one reason not to travel
back in time. 

I’ve only mentioned my top three reasons but of course there are many more. What would be your biggest reason not to travel back in
time?
Here’s a 24-second video from comedian Jeremy Hotz with
his view on camping. 
Mahrie G Reid link
11/2/2013 04:55:30 am

Marlow - finally - happy to see you acknowledging the realities of daily life in the past. Having used somewhat humane outhouses in my childhood and experienced the pot-under-the-bed, I have no desire to go back to that or even further to the options you've listed!

Mary M. Forbes link
11/2/2013 06:14:32 am

Indoor plumbing and gas heating is what I would miss - and of course Tim Horton's coffee too. Since I actually grew up without those conveniences in a really rare scenario - I agree - there is just too much fantasizing and romanticizing the good old days. I've also heard it was a 'simpler' time and that makes me laugh. You only had time to work, work, work just to survive. There wasn't too much time for leisurely activities. A very good article - a reality check. But for stories it's still nice not to deal with all those bad things.

diana link
11/2/2013 02:07:06 pm

I'm with you. The 21st Century for me. I'll keep my 'olden' days to books, movies and theme parks!

Lorraine Paton link
11/4/2013 07:50:37 am

You are right! How DID people survive?

I think the smell would be overpowering. Yuck!

I also can't imagine being trapped in one small tiny square of the world for the entirety of my life (Knowing that I'd have been a peasant and not some fancy knight going off to wars all over Europe) never seeing anything else.

Oh - and getting bled because you're sick... and probably with a dirty knife.

Mary Magdeline link
11/6/2013 09:24:00 am

You're right Lorraine. I use that example any time a person things a doctor is a God. On the other hand - that's where we writer's step in and write about a 'good' witch who uses herbs and home remedies - and she has to be careful she's not caught and burned as a witch.


Comments are closed.
“We are all apprentices in a craft where no one ever becomes a master.”
—Ernest Hemingway
Photos from mararie, libertygrace0, Renaud Camus, David Holt London
  • Marlow's Books
  • Contact Me
  • About Marlow